The Ultimate Big Brother All-Stars 3 Wishlist: 15 New Era Houseguests Poised For Redemption And Glory
The conversation surrounding a third installment of Big Brother All-Stars (BBAS3) has reached a fever pitch in late 2025, driven by a new era of gameplay and the official return of iconic veterans in a new format. While fans eagerly await a full season announcement, CBS has already injected "All-Star" energy into the franchise with the launch of the companion show, Big Brother: Unlocked, confirming that the network is actively engaging its most strategic and compelling former houseguests. This is the deepest dive into the current state of the All-Stars universe, from the new show's hosts to the 15 players from Seasons 23, 24, 25, and 26 who are absolute locks for the next time the call goes out for a legendary cast.
The last true All-Stars season, BB22, left many fans wanting more, but the subsequent seasons—starting with BB23—have delivered a fresh slate of strategic masterminds, compelling characters, and entertaining villains. The current focus is on the groundbreaking companion series for Big Brother 27, which is setting the stage for the next full-scale veteran showdown by bringing back two of the game's most respected winners.
The Current All-Stars Status: Big Brother: Unlocked Hosts and Format
The most concrete and up-to-date "All-Stars" news centers on the new bi-weekly companion show, Big Brother: Unlocked, which is airing alongside Big Brother 27 (2025). This new format is a strategic move by CBS to leverage fan-favorite veterans and provide never-before-seen broadcast footage and exclusive house commentary.
Featured All-Stars & Hosts: Taylor Hale and Derrick Levasseur
The new companion series is co-hosted by two of the franchise's most celebrated winners, bridging the gap between the show's "Old School" and "New Era."
- Taylor Hale (BB24 Winner)
- Season: Big Brother 24 (Winner)
- Hometown: West Bloomfield, Michigan
- Occupation: Personal Stylist / Pageant Queen (Miss Michigan USA 2021)
- Why She's an All-Star: Taylor Hale is one of the most iconic winners of the new era. She overcame relentless bullying and isolation early in her season to become a strategic, social, and emotional force. Her victory was a powerful narrative of resilience, culminating in a historic 8-1 jury vote. She is the first Black woman to win a non-celebrity season of Big Brother.
- Derrick Levasseur (BB16 Winner)
- Season: Big Brother 16 (Winner)
- Hometown: Providence, Rhode Island
- Occupation: Former Police Officer / Private Investigator
- Why He's an All-Star: Derrick is widely regarded as one of the most dominant winners in the show's history. He played a near-perfect game, never being nominated until the very end, and masterfully controlling the house from the shadows. His strategic prowess and ability to build deep, trusting alliances make him an authority on the game.
The involvement of these two winners as hosts confirms that the "All-Star" brand is being actively cultivated. The show is also set to feature a rotating panel of "three BB All-Stars" to offer their expert commentary, suggesting a high-level alumni engagement that could easily transition into a full-blown competitive season.
The Ultimate Big Brother All-Stars 3 Wishlist: 15 New Era Houseguests
With the last full All-Stars season being BB22, the next one—speculated to be Big Brother 28 or BBAS3—is expected to draw heavily from the "New Era" of the game (Seasons 23, 24, 25, and 26). The following houseguests have generated the most fan discussion and are considered the most likely candidates to receive an invitation, based on their strategic gameplay, popularity, and ability to create compelling television. This list is a blend of winners, strategic powerhouses, and beloved fan favorites.
The Strategic Masterminds and Power Players
These players proved they could dominate the game, whether through competition wins or social maneuvering. Their return would guarantee high-level gameplay.
- Tiffany Mitchell (BB23): The strategic architect of The Cookout alliance. Her ability to manage a six-person secret alliance while maintaining a strong social game makes her a must-see returning player. She is often cited as a lock for a future All-Stars season.
- Michael Bruner (BB24): The ultimate competition beast of his season, setting a new record for most Veto wins in a single season. His comp record is undeniable, but his social game needs refinement, making his return a high-stakes proposition.
- Jag Bains (BB25): The winner of BB25, Jag holds the record for most combined competition wins in a single season. His late-game dominance and ability to survive an early eviction make him a formidable, proven winner.
- Derek Xiao (BB23): A fan-favorite and strategic threat who was taken out too early. Known for his intelligence, composure, and being a strong competitor, his potential for a deep run is immense.
- Cirie Fields (BB25): Though a legend in another reality TV sphere, her performance in the Big Brother house, navigating the game with her son, and her social awareness make her a compelling strategic returnee.
The Social and Underdog Favorites
These houseguests captured the hearts of the audience with their engaging personalities, dramatic storylines, or impressive social games.
- Matt Turner (BB24): An integral part of the dominant Leftovers alliance and a runner-up. Turner's strategic mind, surprising competition wins, and humorous personality make him a strong casting choice.
- America Lopez (BB25): A strong social player who became a fan favorite for her witty commentary and late-game strategic push alongside her showmance, Cory.
- Cory Wurtenburger (BB25): The youngest houseguest of his season, Cory showed incredible strategic maturity and was a key part of the season's most enduring showmance. His intellectual approach to the game is highly valued by fans.
- Claire Rehfuss (BB23): A strategic player who was unfortunately blindsided by The Cookout. Her intelligence and desire for revenge against the dominant alliance of her season would make for great television.
- Kyland Young (BB23): A member of The Cookout, Kyland was a major strategic force and a strong competitor. His complex and often polarizing gameplay would add significant drama to an All-Stars season.
The Wildcards and Redemption Stories
These players either left too soon, made a single fatal mistake, or are simply too entertaining to leave out of a second chance season.
- Azah Awasum (BB23): A member of The Cookout whose social game was underrated. Her return would give her a chance to step out of the shadows of her alliance and play an individual game.
- Alyssa Lopez (BB23): A strong social player whose showmance became her downfall. She has a high ceiling for competition wins and a fresh perspective on the game.
- Britney Haynes (BB12/14): While not from the "New Era," including one or two classic, beloved players like Britney (known for her hilarious diary room sessions) is essential for bridging the generations of fans and adding topical authority.
- James Rhine (BB6/7): Another classic veteran known for his competitive spirit and being a key figure in the first All-Stars season. His inclusion would be a nod to the show's history.
- Janelle Pierzina (BB6/7/14/22): The undisputed Queen of Big Brother. While she was on BB22, no true All-Stars conversation is complete without mentioning the possibility of her return, even if only for a short, legendary appearance.
Why Big Brother All-Stars 3 is Inevitable
The current climate suggests that Big Brother All-Stars 3 is not a matter of "if," but "when." The show's producers have successfully created a new crop of viable, non-problematic, and highly strategic houseguests in the post-BB22 era. The fan base is clamoring for a season that pits the new school against itself, and perhaps throws in a few classic legends to keep them on their toes. The key factors driving this inevitability are clear.
First, the sheer quality of the players from BB23 through BB26 is too high to ignore. Players like Tiffany Mitchell and Derek Xiao were cut down by a dominant, pre-game alliance structure, and need a proper second chance.
Second, the introduction of Big Brother: Unlocked, featuring winners like Taylor Hale and Derrick Levasseur, proves that CBS is keen on using its veteran talent to drive viewership and engagement. This show serves as a perfect testing ground for which alumni are ready and willing to commit to the intense, multi-month process of playing the game again.
Finally, the gap between the last two All-Stars seasons (BB7 in 2006 and BB22 in 2020) was 14 years. Waiting another decade is simply not an option given the explosion of reality TV and the need to capitalize on current fan excitement. A BBAS3 season focusing on the "New Era" is the perfect way to revitalize the franchise and deliver the legendary season that fans have been waiting for since 2020.
Detail Author:
- Name : Kaleigh Rogahn
- Username : ctowne
- Email : krajcik.shana@schaefer.org
- Birthdate : 1976-04-11
- Address : 56441 Okuneva Hill Apt. 299 Trantowstad, DE 83384-5261
- Phone : +1 (424) 982-7453
- Company : Hettinger Inc
- Job : Municipal Clerk
- Bio : Nemo praesentium qui dolor. Voluptas voluptatem est aliquam temporibus reiciendis ad adipisci. Odio nostrum dignissimos deleniti atque. Voluptates deleniti eius et quia nobis a.
Socials
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/willisfahey
- username : willisfahey
- bio : Atque natus vel non sapiente qui. Dolorum et quas ut sed et ad. Soluta et et dolor soluta voluptatem. Dolorem consequatur corrupti vitae est.
- followers : 6715
- following : 327
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/willis_fahey
- username : willis_fahey
- bio : Ut non culpa nam voluptatum vero. Dolores sed eius nihil est. Aspernatur dignissimos iure illo.
- followers : 2498
- following : 1593
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@wfahey
- username : wfahey
- bio : Dolorem ullam quisquam consequatur voluptas.
- followers : 2052
- following : 1158
